Disclosure: Money Zoomer may earn a commission if you sign up for a product through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Our opinions are our own, and a commission never changes what we write. See our Editorial Guidelines for how we review products.
Financial Disclaimer: This review is for general educational purposes only and is not personalized financial, tax, legal, or investment advice. Health savings accounts carry rules on contributions, distributions, and eligibility, and investment returns are not guaranteed. Fees, rates, and product terms change, so confirm current details on the provider website and in the deposit agreement before opening an account. Money Zoomer is not a licensed financial advisor.
Last updated: November 13, 2026. Fees, APY, investment terms, and regulatory details were checked against published information, official support pages, and independent reviews at that date. Always confirm current terms on Lively’s own website before opening an account.
Lively is the HSA that fixed the parts of the HSA experience that banks never bothered to fix. It was founded in 2016 by two friends who had watched family members struggle with high-deductible health plans, and it built a product around a simple observation: HSAs were being run by banks that treated them as a sideline, on decade-old software, with fees that ate the balance a person was trying to grow. Lively offered a clean app, $0 monthly fees for individuals, a free debit card, and—crucially—a self-directed Charles Schwab brokerage account inside the HSA, so you could invest your balance in almost anything without moving to a different provider.
That combination is genuinely strong, and it is why Investopedia named Lively its “Runner Up” in the 2026 best-HSA rankings, behind only Fidelity. Independent comparisons consistently describe Lively as the cleanest landing spot for a trustee-to-trustee HSA transfer, and as a good alternative to Fidelity if you prefer to work with an HSA specialist rather than a large brokerage.
But Lively is not a free lunch, and the gap between its marketing and its economics is worth understanding before you move your balance. The Schwab brokerage access costs $24 a year unless you keep $3,000 in cash, which earns a near-zero APY—so the “free” investing option is really a choice between a small annual fee and a large opportunity cost. The guided portfolio option charges 0.50% annually, which is more expensive than Fidelity’s 0.35% managed option. And the cash yield is low even by HSA standards, at roughly 0.01%–0.12%, versus 3.37% available at Fidelity.
This review looks at what Lively actually offers, what it costs, how the two investment paths work, where it beats Fidelity and where it does not, and who should—and should not—move their HSA to Lively.
Lively HSA at a Glance
| Category | Details |
|---|---|
| What it is | A fintech HSA provider offering individual and employer accounts, with investing through Charles Schwab and Devenir |
| Founded | 2016, originally as HealtheeSavings, Inc.; Y Combinator Winter 2017 batch; based in San Francisco |
| Regulatory status | IRS-approved nonbank trustee under Treasury Regulation 1.408-2(e), approved March 22, 2021 |
| Not a bank | Lively is not FDIC-insured itself; cash is held at FDIC-member partner banks and may qualify for pass-through insurance |
| Monthly fee | $0 for individuals and families |
| Other fees | $0 account opening, closing, transfer, debit card, excess contribution, or minimum balance fees |
| Schwab brokerage access | $24/year**, or **$0 if you keep a $3,000 minimum cash balance |
| Guided portfolio (Devenir) | 0.50% annually on invested assets, plus ~0.23% average fund expense ratio |
| Cash APY | 0.02%–0.12% standard (FDIC-insured); HSA Boost at 0.15%–1.06% APY is opt-in and not FDIC-insured |
| Assets on platform | $2 billion as of May 2025 (company-stated) |
| Best for | Individuals who want a modern HSA app, a free Schwab brokerage window, and are willing to manage the cash-threshold trade-off |
| Skip it if | You want a competitive cash yield or the lowest possible all-in cost; Fidelity is the stronger benchmark |
What Is Lively HSA and How Does It Work?
Lively is a financial technology company, not a bank. The HSA is administered by Lively, Inc., which holds an IRS nonbank trustee approval—the licence that allows it to act as custodian of HSA assets. The cash balance sits at partner banks and credit unions that are FDIC-insured, and the debit card is issued by Choice Financial Group under a Visa licence. The brokerage is a Charles Schwab Health Savings Brokerage Account (HSBA), and the guided portfolios are managed by Devenir, an investment firm that specialises in HSA advisory.
The structure is straightforward. You open an HSA through Lively, link a funding source, and receive a spending account with a debit card. Contributions go into the cash account. If you want to invest, you have two paths:
-
Self-directed investing through the Schwab HSBA, where you can buy stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, and bonds with $0 commissions, and where Lively’s dashboard shows your portfolio alongside your cash balance without a separate Schwab login.
-
HSA Guided Portfolio through Devenir, a managed option with three risk profiles (Conservative, Moderate, Aggressive) and automatic rebalancing.
Lively also offers Expense Scout, a tool that scans linked bank and credit card accounts for forgotten qualified expenses and prompts you to claim them tax-free, and Claim Sync, which integrates with 95%+ of health plans to auto-import Explanation of Benefits data and pre-fill claims for one-tap approval. Those spending tools are a genuine differentiator: they are built for the reimbursement side of an HSA, which is where most providers offer nothing beyond a receipt upload.
Fees and Costs: The Real Structure
Lively’s headline is $0 monthly fees, and that is true for the individual account. But the investment costs are where the economics live, and they are more layered than the marketing suggests.
| Fee | Amount | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly maintenance | $0 | Always, for individuals and families |
| Account opening, closing, transfer | $0 | All |
| Debit cards (up to 3) | $0 | All |
| Schwab brokerage access | $24/year**, **or $0 with a $3,000 cash minimum | If you invest via Schwab |
| Guided portfolio (Devenir) | 0.50% annually on invested assets, plus ~0.23% fund expenses | If you choose the managed option |
| Underlying Schwab fund fees | Varies; Schwab’s own funds and many ETFs are low-cost, but additional fees from Charles Schwab may apply | On Schwab investments |
Source: Lively pricing page; Lively vs Fidelity comparison; independent reviews.
The $24 brokerage fee** is the number that shapes behaviour. It is small in absolute terms—**$2 a month—but it creates an explicit trade-off: pay $24 a year**, or keep **$3,000 in cash earning roughly 0.02%–0.12% APY. On $3,000**, that APY earns between **$0.60 and $3.60 a year**. The **opportunity cost** of holding the cash threshold is the difference between what that $3,000 could earn elsewhere—3.37% at Fidelity** would be about $101 a year**—and what it earns at Lively. In other words, **keeping $3,000 in cash to avoid the $24 fee costs you roughly $100 in forgone interest. Paying the $24 and investing the cash is the better financial choice for most investors, which makes the “free” framing slightly misleading.
The guided portfolio at 0.50% is expensive relative to Fidelity Go at 0.35% for balances of $25,000 or more**, and it sits on top of fund expenses. For a hands-off investor with a large HSA, the managed fee difference is meaningful: on **$50,000, 0.50% is $250 a year** versus **$175 at 0.35%, before fund costs.
Investment Options: Schwab Versus Devenir
Lively’s two investment paths serve different investors, and the choice matters.
The Schwab HSBA is the reason most self-directed investors choose Lively. It offers stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and ETFs with $0 commissions, and it is a full brokerage account rather than a curated menu. Independent comparisons note that the Schwab window offers commission-free trades on over 100 ETFs, with the caveat that Vanguard ETFs are excluded from that commission-free list. The Lively dashboard tracks your portfolio natively, so you do not need a separate Schwab login to see your invested balance alongside your cash.
The Devenir HSA Guided Portfolio is the hands-off option. It offers three risk profiles—Conservative, Moderate, and Aggressive—with automatic rebalancing. It is a reasonable choice for someone who wants a diversified portfolio without picking funds, but at 0.50% annually plus ~0.23% in fund expenses, it is a costly way to hold a simple portfolio. A low-cost target-date or balanced fund inside the Schwab window would likely cost a fraction of that.
The absence of a single “auto-sweep” toggle is a minor limitation worth noting. Fidelity allows you to set a cash threshold and automatically invest anything above it, whereas Lively’s Schwab integration requires you to move cash into the brokerage manually or via a recurring transfer. For a disciplined investor, that is a small inconvenience; for someone who wants true automation, it is a gap.
Cash APY: The Weakest Number
Lively’s standard cash yield is 0.02%–0.12% APY, FDIC-insured through partner banks. That is effectively zero. On $5,000**, 0.12% earns **$6 a year. On $10,000**, it earns **$12.
Lively offers an HSA Boost product that advertises 0.15%–1.06% APY, but it is opt-in and not FDIC-insured—it is a separate program with different terms, and the top of that range still does not approach what is available on cash at Fidelity. The standard cash rate is the number most users will experience, and it is the single clearest reason Lively is not the best choice for someone who holds a large uninvested HSA balance.
For context, Fidelity’s HSA cash sweep into FDRXX (Fidelity Government Cash Reserves) yielded 3.37% APY as of July 31, 2026—variable, SIPC-protected, and not FDIC-insured. The gap between 0.12% and 3.37% is roughly $325 a year on a $10,000 cash balance. That is a real cost, and it does not appear in the “$0 monthly fee” headline.
Customer Experience and Reviews
Lively’s customer-satisfaction profile is positive but not uniform, and the complaints cluster around specific operational issues rather than the core product.
The positive signals are strong. Trustpilot reviewers praise the ease of setup, the convenient debit card, the ability to invest through Schwab, and US-based customer support that fixes problems quickly. One reviewer who had been “passed around” between HSA custodians said Lively made them feel like they had “control over my HSA again”. Another described the setup as “super easy” and the support agents as “extremely helpful”. G2 shows a 4.7/5 rating from 119 reviews, and app-store data shows a 4.84 rating.
The complaints are specific and worth noting. Reviewers report bugs and errors in account transactions, forced use of the website for some features, lack of credential memory, and issues on rooted devices. The account creation process has drawn complaints, including at least one report of an application being denied for “security reasons” without a clear explanation. More seriously, some users report difficulty resolving issues that sit between Lively and Devenir—the guided portfolio provider—with support loops where “Lively says call Devenir, Devenir said nothing”. That is the kind of multi-vendor friction that a fintech wrapper can create, and it is a legitimate reason to prefer a single-provider platform if you value clean accountability.
The absence of a major regulatory enforcement action against Lively is a positive data point. The company holds an IRS nonbank trustee approval that remains on the published list as of April 1, 2026, and there is no public SEC or FINRA disciplinary record comparable to what some competing platforms carry. That is not a guarantee of perfection, but it is a cleaner record than several platforms reviewed on this site.
Pros and Cons
Pros
-
$0 monthly fees for individuals and families, with no account opening, closing, transfer, or debit card fees.
-
A genuine self-directed brokerage window through Charles Schwab, with stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, and bonds and $0 commissions.
-
Native portfolio tracking in the Lively dashboard, so you do not need a separate Schwab login.
-
Strong spending tools. Expense Scout finds forgotten qualified expenses, and Claim Sync auto-imports EOB data from 95%+ of health plans.
-
Positive customer-support reviews, with multiple users praising US-based, responsive agents.
-
IRS-approved nonbank trustee, with a clean regulatory record and no major enforcement actions.
-
A clean landing spot for HSA transfers, with $0 transfer fees and a modern onboarding flow.
Cons
-
The Schwab brokerage access costs $24/year** unless you keep **$3,000 in cash, which earns a near-zero APY—so the “free” investing option has a real opportunity cost.
-
Low standard cash APY (0.02%–0.12%), far below the 3.37% available at Fidelity.
-
The guided portfolio charges 0.50% annually, more than Fidelity’s 0.35% managed option, plus ~0.23% in fund expenses.
-
No single auto-sweep toggle for Schwab investing; you must move cash manually or via recurring transfers.
-
Multi-vendor friction between Lively and Devenir has caused support loops for some guided-portfolio users.
-
App bugs and account-creation friction are recurring complaints, including at least one unexplained denial.
-
Lively is not a bank; cash insurance depends on partner banks and pass-through FDIC coverage, which is less straightforward than a single insured institution.
How Lively Compares to Other HSA Providers
| Provider | Monthly fee | Investment access | Investment cost | Cash APY | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lively | $0 | Schwab full brokerage or Devenir guided | $24/yr** or **$3,000 cash; 0.50% guided | 0.02%–0.12% | Modern app, Schwab access, spending tools |
| Fidelity HSA | $0 | Full Fidelity brokerage | $0 | 3.37% (FDRXX) | Most people, especially long-term investors |
| Starship HSA | $0** spending; **$1 investing | 3 ETF portfolios | **$1/mo + 0.35%** above $5k | 0.01%–0.05% | Mobile-first simplicity |
| HealthEquity | **$2.95** (waived over $2k) | 30+ mutual funds | Varies | 0.05% | Employer-sponsored plans |
Sources: WalletGrower comparison; Lively vs Fidelity guide; Starship and HealthEquity data as cited in the table.
The comparison is blunt. Fidelity is the benchmark: $0 fees, $0 minimum, full brokerage access, and 3.37% on cash. Lively beats Fidelity on spending tools—Expense Scout and Claim Sync have no direct Fidelity equivalent—and on the native dashboard integration of the Schwab account. Lively also has a cleaner, more modern app than most HSA providers, and its customer support reviews are strong. But on the two numbers that matter most for long-term HSA growth—cash yield and investment cost—Fidelity is better. Lively’s $24 fee or $3,000 cash trap and its 0.50% guided fee make it a more expensive home for a large, invested HSA balance than Fidelity, even though the headline monthly fee is the same.
The choice therefore turns on how you use the HSA. If you spend from it regularly and value receipt tracking and claim automation, Lively’s tools are a genuine advantage. If you invest for the long term and hold a large balance, Fidelity’s zero-cost brokerage and high cash yield are hard to beat.
Who Should Use Lively HSA?
Lively may suit you if you…
-
Want a modern, easy-to-use HSA app and are willing to pay $24 a year** (or hold **$3,000 in cash) for full Schwab brokerage access.
-
Spend from your HSA regularly and want Expense Scout and Claim Sync to automate receipt tracking and claims.
-
Are transferring an HSA from a bank with dated software and want a $0-fee landing spot with a clean onboarding process.
-
Value US-based customer support and a provider with a clean regulatory record.
-
Want self-directed investing in stocks and ETFs, rather than a curated fund menu.
You should probably skip it if you…
-
Want a competitive cash yield; Fidelity’s 3.37% is dramatically better than Lively’s 0.02%–0.12%.
-
Are building a large, long-term invested HSA and want the lowest all-in cost; Fidelity’s $0** brokerage and **$0 minimum are cheaper than Lively’s $24 fee** or **$3,000 cash threshold.
-
Want a hands-off managed portfolio and are fee-sensitive; Lively’s 0.50% guided fee is higher than Fidelity Go’s 0.35%.
-
Need true automation; Lively lacks a single auto-sweep toggle for Schwab investing.
-
Have had account-creation or app-reliability issues with fintech platforms in the past; Lively is not immune to those complaints.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Lively HSA a bank?
No. Lively is a fintech company and an IRS-approved nonbank trustee. Cash is held at FDIC-member partner banks, and the debit card is issued by Choice Financial Group.
Is Lively HSA free?
The individual HSA has $0 monthly fees** and **$0 account opening, closing, transfer, and debit card fees. Investing through Schwab costs $24/year** unless you keep **$3,000 in cash, and the guided portfolio charges 0.50% annually.
What APY does Lively HSA pay on cash?
0.02%–0.12% APY on the standard FDIC-insured cash balance. The HSA Boost option advertises 0.15%–1.06% APY, is opt-in, and is not FDIC-insured.
How does Lively invest my HSA?
Through two paths: a Charles Schwab Health Savings Brokerage Account for self-directed investing in stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, and bonds, or an HSA Guided Portfolio managed by Devenir with three risk profiles and automatic rebalancing.
Is Lively HSA FDIC insured?
Lively itself is not FDIC-insured. Cash balances are held at FDIC-member partner banks and may qualify for pass-through insurance if conditions are met. Invested funds are held at Schwab and are SIPC-protected, not FDIC-insured.
Does Lively HSA have a debit card?
Yes. A Visa debit card issued by Choice Financial Group is included, and Lively charges $0 for up to three cards.
Is Lively HSA better than Fidelity?
It depends on how you use the HSA. Lively has better spending tools (Expense Scout, Claim Sync) and a cleaner app. Fidelity has a better cash yield (3.37% vs 0.02%–0.12%), $0 investing costs with no cash threshold, and a lower guided fee. For long-term investors, Fidelity is the stronger choice; for regular spenders who want automation, Lively is competitive.
Final Verdict
Lively is a genuinely good HSA product built by people who understood what was wrong with the category. The $0 monthly fee, the clean app, the Schwab brokerage window, and the Expense Scout and Claim Sync tools make it one of the more thoughtful HSA platforms available, and the positive support reviews and clean regulatory record are real assets. For someone transferring from a bank HSA with dated software and nickel-and-dime fees, Lively is a clear upgrade.
But the headline “$0″** conceals a **real cost structure**. The **$24 brokerage fee or $3,000 cash threshold** is a trade-off, not a freebie, and the **near-zero cash APY** makes the cash threshold expensive in opportunity cost. The **0.50% guided portfolio** is **more expensive than Fidelity’s 0.35%** managed option, and the **absence of an auto-sweep toggle** means Lively is less automated than it appears. Against **Fidelity—$0 fees, $0 minimum, full brokerage, 3.37% cash yield—Lively wins on spending tools and app design and loses on cash yield and all-in investment cost.
The honest verdict is that Lively is the best choice for someone who actively spends from their HSA and wants receipt tracking and claim automation, and a reasonable but not optimal choice for a long-term investor who values the Schwab integration and the app experience enough to accept the $24 fee and the low cash yield. If you are building a large HSA and want the lowest-cost path, Fidelity remains the benchmark. If you want a modern HSA with strong spending tools and are willing to manage the cash-threshold trade-off, Lively is a legitimate contender.
Before opening an account, confirm the current cash APY, the $24 brokerage fee terms**, and the **Schwab fund commission list** on Lively’s website. The gap between the **$0 headline and the real cost of investing is the most important thing to understand about this platform.



